As of November 2026, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) says the evidence is insufficient to weigh the benefits and harms of a routine visual skin exam by a clinician for teens and adults who have no signs or symptoms. That is its final recommendation from April 18, 2023, and it is not advice against screening. The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) encourages people to check their own skin regularly, to see a board-certified dermatologist about any spot that is new, different or changing, and to talk with a dermatologist about their own risk.
What the USPSTF reviewed, and what an "I statement" means
The USPSTF is an independent volunteer panel that reviews research on preventive care, such as screening tests, and grades how strong the evidence is. Its skin cancer screening recommendation, published April 18, 2023, asked a narrow question: when a clinician looks over the skin of someone with no symptoms, does that lead to fewer deaths or less illness from skin cancer, and what harms come with it?
According to the Task Force, the research did not settle it. A population screening program in one German state was linked to fewer melanoma deaths at 5 years, but the difference had faded by 10 years, and a nationwide program in Germany showed no observable effect on deaths. Most other studies were not randomized. On the harm side, the Task Force weighed scarring from biopsies, worry, and overdiagnosis, which means finding cancers that would never have caused a problem and treating them anyway.
So the grade is "I," for insufficient evidence. An A or B means the Task Force recommends a service, C means it may suit some people, D means it recommends against it, and I means the balance of benefits and harms can't yet be determined. The Task Force adds that clinicians should use their judgment about whether to screen.
That means the I statement is not a recommendation against skin checks, and it doesn't call screening useless or harmful. It also doesn't apply to everyone.
The AAD's response, issued the same day, made that point and noted that the Task Force was not commenting on the value of screening by dermatologists. The National Cancer Institute's patient summary on skin cancer screening (updated May 2025) takes a similar line: skin exams have not been shown to lower skin cancer deaths in the general population, and regular checks by a doctor remain important for people who have already had skin cancer.
Who the USPSTF statement covers, and who it doesn't
The recommendation covers teens and adults who have no symptoms and no history of precancerous or cancerous skin lesions. The Task Force's clinician summary says it does not apply to people:
- with symptoms, such as changes in the size, shape or color of a skin growth, an irregular mole, or a spot that looks suspicious
- with a personal or family history of skin cancer
- already being watched closely because of high risk, such as people with an inherited condition like familial atypical mole and melanoma syndrome
If any of these describes you, the I statement is not about you. A dermatologist can help you decide how often your skin should be checked.
What the American Academy of Dermatology advises
The AAD's public pages focus on self-checks, quick action on changes, and personal risk:
- Check your own skin regularly. The AAD's 2023 statement encourages everyone to act as their own health advocate. Its self-exam guide covers a head-to-toe check with a full-length mirror and a hand mirror, including the scalp, palms, soles and between the toes. Our monthly self-exam checklist turns that into steps.
- See a board-certified dermatologist about changes. The AAD advises a visit for a new spot, a spot that looks different from your others, or one that changes, itches or bleeds.
- Ask about your own schedule. The AAD's risk page tells people to ask their dermatologist how often to have a full-body exam, since that depends on their risk and any past skin cancer. Its statement adds that people at higher risk should be especially watchful.
What happens during a skin cancer screening
A screening is a visual exam. The USPSTF describes a clinician looking at the skin with the naked eye or with a dermatoscope, a lighted magnifying tool (using one is called dermoscopy). Clinicians often apply the ABCDE rule (asymmetry, border, color, diameter, evolving) or the "ugly duckling" sign, meaning a spot unlike the rest. A biopsy, in which a small sample goes to a lab, is what confirms or rules out skin cancer. The AAD recommends a full-body exam whenever possible. For a step-by-step look, see what a good skin cancer screening includes.
Risk factors that change the picture
The USPSTF and the AAD name many of the same risk factors:
- Ultraviolet (UV) exposure from the sun, tanning beds or sunlamps, plus frequent or blistering sunburns
- Fair skin that burns or freckles, light eyes, and red or blond hair
- Many moles (the AAD mentions 50 or more) or unusual-looking (atypical) moles
- A personal or family history of skin cancer
- Older age (the AAD lists 50 or older) and, per the USPSTF, male sex
- A weakened immune system or an organ transplant, according to the AAD
Skin cancer affects people of every skin tone. The USPSTF notes that people with darker skin are often diagnosed at a later stage, and that the most common type of melanoma among Black people tends to appear on the palms, the soles or under the nails. A risk factor raises the odds; it doesn't predict what will happen to you.
So should you get screened?
Neither group sets one schedule for everyone. The USPSTF leaves the decision for people without symptoms to clinician judgment, and the AAD points people toward self-checks plus a conversation with a dermatologist about their own risk. Our post on when to get a skin cancer screening covers timing.
Short FAQ
Is a skin cancer screening covered by insurance? Coverage varies by plan, so check with your plan or call (347) 497-4984. Bay Ridge Dermatology accepts most insurances, including Aetna, BCBS, Cigna, United, Medicare, Oxford, Empire and Humana. Our insurance page has more.
Does a screening hurt? The exam itself is a look at your skin, so it isn't painful. If a spot needs a biopsy, your dermatologist will explain what's involved first.
Do I need one if I check my own skin? Self-checks help, but the AAD presents them as working alongside dermatologist exams, not replacing them. A dermatologist can see places you can't, such as your back and scalp.
When to book a dermatologist now
Don't wait for a routine screening if you notice:
- a spot that showed up recently and stands out from the rest
- a mole that is getting bigger, or whose outline or color is shifting
- itching, bleeding or crusting in a spot
- a sore or patch that won't heal, or heals and comes back
- a dark line running along a fingernail or toenail
- a pearly or shiny bump, or a rough patch that lingers
Bay Ridge Dermatology offers full-body skin exams at 515 84th Street in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn. Dr. Evangeline Perez is a board-certified dermatologist with more than 20 years of experience. If you'd like a skin check, or want to talk through your own risk, book online or call (347) 497-4984.
This article is general information, not medical advice. For advice about your own skin, see a dermatologist.

