To verify that a Brooklyn dermatologist is really in your insurance network, check three sources: your insurer's online provider directory, your insurer's member services line, and the dermatology office itself. Ask each one about your exact plan, not just the insurance company, and about the specific clinician you plan to see. Write down who told you what, and when. If a directory turns out to be wrong, the federal No Surprises Act gives you some protection, as the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) describes below.
This guide is about confirming one practice you've already picked. If you're still looking for candidates, start with our guide to finding a dermatologist who is accepting new patients.
Why provider directories can be wrong
The federal No Surprises Act set rules to improve the accuracy of insurers' directories, as CMS explains (more on that below). Even so, a listing can fall behind. A few ordinary reasons:
- Networks change. Contracts between practices and plans start and end, sometimes partway through the year.
- People and places change. Clinicians join or leave practices, and offices move or open new locations.
- One insurer, many networks. A single insurance company can sell many plans, such as HMO, PPO, EPO, Medicare Advantage or marketplace plans, and each may use a different network. A practice can be in network for some of an insurer's plans and not others.
- "In network" and "accepting new patients" are different questions. A listing can be right about one and wrong about the other.
So treat a directory listing as a starting point, not a final answer.
The three-way check, step by step
Step 1: Your insurer's directory. If the directory lets you choose a plan, pick your exact plan before you search. Search for dermatology near your ZIP code (11209 in Bay Ridge, for example) and open the listing for the practice. Check that the practice name, address, clinician name and specialty all match, and that the listing says it's in network for your plan by name.
Step 2: Your insurer's member services. Call the number on the back of your insurance card. Ask:
- "Is [practice name] at [address] in network for my plan?" Give the plan name and member ID from your card.
- "Is [clinician's name] in network at that location?"
- "Do I need a referral or prior authorization for a dermatology visit?"
- "What will I owe for a specialist visit, and does my deductible apply?"
Ask the representative to confirm the answer in writing if they can, such as through your member account or by email.
Step 3: The dermatology office. Call the practice and give your plan name exactly as it appears on your card. Ask whether the practice participates in that plan, whether the clinician you're booking with does too, and whether the reason for your visit is something usually billed to insurance. Cosmetic treatments, for example, generally aren't covered.
If the insurer and the office give you different answers, ask the insurer to look into it before your appointment.
Write it down
Keep a simple record of each check. It takes a few minutes and can matter a lot if a bill arrives that doesn't match what you were told.
- the date and time of each call, and the number you called
- the name of the person you spoke with
- any call reference or confirmation number
- what they said, in their words
- your plan name and member ID
- the clinician's name and the office address that were confirmed
- dated screenshots of the directory listing
Keep any written confirmation and your explanation of benefits (EOB) statements after the visit. Your EOB shows how your plan processed each claim, which helps if you need to question a bill.
Your protections under the federal No Surprises Act
CMS explains the No Surprises Act's directory rules in its Overview of Key Consumer Protections (revised June 2026). According to CMS, health plans and insurers must:
- verify and update their provider directory information at least once every 90 days
- update their database within two business days of receiving changes from a provider
- remove providers they can't verify as in network within a set timeframe
- post directories on a public website with each in-network provider's name, address, specialty, phone number and digital contact information
- answer questions about a provider's network status within one business day
CMS also explains what happens when a directory is wrong. If you get care from an out-of-network provider because the directory had incorrect information, your cost-sharing can't be more than you would have paid in network, and the plan must count it toward your in-network deductible and out-of-pocket maximum. If you already paid more than the in-network amount, CMS says you're entitled to a refund of the difference from the provider, plus interest. CMS adds that formal regulations for these directory rules are still to come, and that plans are expected to follow a good-faith reading of the law in the meantime.
CMS lists the coverage these protections apply to, including job-based plans and individual plans bought on or off the Health Insurance Marketplace. It notes that the act's surprise billing protections don't apply to people whose coverage is only through Medicare (including Medicare Advantage) or Medicaid, because those programs already have their own protections against balance billing. If you have Medicare or Medicaid, ask your plan how a directory error would be handled.
New York has its own rule as well. In a December 2022 announcement, the New York State Department of Financial Services (DFS), which regulates insurers in the state, said a new regulation means consumers who relied on incorrect network information from their insurer pay no more than their in-network cost-sharing. DFS has more detail on its website.
For help with a billing problem, CMS runs the No Surprises Help Desk at 1-800-985-3059. This section is a summary for patients, not legal advice.
The clinician matters, not just the practice
A practice and the people who work there can have different network status. A clinician who recently joined may not be listed yet, and the network status of one clinician doesn't automatically carry over to another. So:
- confirm the specific clinician by name, not just the practice
- confirm the office address, if the practice has more than one location
- check again if your appointment is moved to a different clinician
Checking Bay Ridge Dermatology
Bay Ridge Dermatology accepts most insurances, including Aetna, BCBS, Cigna, United, Medicare, Oxford, Empire and Humana. Because each insurer offers many plans, please call us with your exact plan name and member ID, and ask about the clinician you'd like to see. Our clinicians are Dr. Evangeline Perez, a board-certified dermatologist; Nicole Marie Colucci, PA-C; and Kerry Ly, PA-C. Then confirm with your insurer, too.
Cosmetic treatments and hair restoration are not covered by insurance. For more on billing, see our insurance page and payment page. Our phone, fax and email are on the contact page.
When you're ready to book, book online or call (347) 497-4984.
This article is general information, not medical advice. For advice about your own skin, see a dermatologist.

