When you show a dermatologist a mole that worries you, they ask about its history, look at it closely and decide whether it needs testing. If it does, they take a small sample, called a biopsy, and send it to a lab, because only a lab can confirm what a spot is. At Bay Ridge Dermatology, that sample is taken with a shave biopsy in the office. What happens next depends on the result: many spots need nothing more, some skin cancers can be treated in the office when the clinician finds it appropriate, and melanoma is diagnosed here and referred to NYC cancer centers for treatment.
The exam: your history, the ABCDE signs and a close look
A suspicious mole evaluation usually starts with questions, whether you came in about one spot or for a routine skin cancer screening. Expect to be asked:
- When you first noticed the spot, and whether it has changed
- Whether it itches, bleeds, crusts or hurts
- Whether you or a close relative has had skin cancer
- About past sunburns, tanning and time spent outdoors
- Which medicines and supplements you take, including blood thinners
Then the clinician looks at the spot itself. The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) teaches the ABCDEs of melanoma as a guide:
- Asymmetry: the two halves look different.
- Border: ragged, notched or fuzzy edges.
- Color: several shades, or color that is patchy.
- Diameter: wider than about 6 millimeters (around the width of a pencil eraser), although melanoma can be smaller.
- Evolving: the spot is changing in size, shape, color or height.
Dermatologists also compare the spot with your other moles. One that stands out from the rest, sometimes called the "ugly duckling," gets a closer look. Dermatologists often examine a spot through a dermatoscope, a lighted handheld magnifier that shows details the naked eye can miss. Our page on what to expect at your first visit explains how appointments work.
By the end of the exam, there are usually three paths: the spot looks harmless, it's worth watching, or it should be biopsied.
Why a biopsy, and how a shave biopsy works
MedlinePlus, from the National Library of Medicine, notes that shave biopsies are often done when a skin cancer is suspected. In general terms, it goes like this:
- The skin is cleaned and numbed, often with a small injection, so you shouldn't feel the sample being taken.
- A small blade removes the top layers of skin, taking all or part of the spot.
- Bleeding is controlled and a bandage goes on. Stitches usually aren't needed.
- The sample is sent to a lab.
The site may be tender for a few days. MedlinePlus lists infection and scarring among the risks, and notes that a shave biopsy leaves a small indented area in the skin. Individual results vary. Follow the aftercare instructions you're given, and call the office if you notice spreading redness, swelling, pus or a fever. Mention any blood thinners first, but don't stop a prescribed medicine on your own.
Shave biopsies are done in the office at Bay Ridge Dermatology as part of its in-office procedures. The practice does not perform punch or excisional biopsies. In general, the right method depends on a spot's size, depth, location and how suspicious it looks.
Waiting for results
After the biopsy, a pathologist (a doctor who specializes in examining tissue) studies the sample under a microscope and writes a report. Your clinician reviews that report and explains what it means for you.
Timing and methods vary, so before you leave the office, ask:
- How and when you'll hear back
- Who to call if you haven't heard by then
- Whether a follow-up visit is needed either way
When the results come in, ask what the spot was, whether it was fully removed, whether anything more is needed, and when your next skin check should be.
What can be treated in the office at Bay Ridge
Many biopsies show a harmless mole, and nothing more is needed. When a biopsy does show skin cancer, the next step depends on the type, size, depth and location of the cancer, and on your overall health.
Bay Ridge Dermatology offers two non-surgical skin cancer treatments, used when the clinician finds them appropriate:
- Electrodesiccation and curettage (ED&C). The growth is scraped away with a curette, a small instrument with a rounded edge, and heat from an electric current destroys remaining cancer cells. The AAD describes ED&C as an option for low-risk basal cell carcinoma, such as a small tumor on the back, belly, arms or thighs in a person with a healthy immune system. It also says ED&C can be effective for squamous cell carcinoma that hasn't grown too deeply, when the doctor selects the right patient.
- Deep shave with topical chemotherapy. The growth is removed with a deeper shave, and then a prescription medicine that treats skin cancer is applied to the skin. The AAD notes that fluorouracil (5-FU), a chemotherapy cream, is FDA-approved to treat superficial basal cell carcinoma, a type found only in the outermost layer of skin. It also notes that the cure rate for medicine applied to the skin is lower than for surgery.
Your clinician decides case by case whether either method fits, and individual results vary.
What Bay Ridge does not do
Bay Ridge Dermatology does not perform:
- Surgical excision of skin cancer, including Mohs surgery
- Punch biopsies or excisional biopsies
- Excisional mole removal
- Melanoma treatment
Melanoma is diagnosed in the office at Bay Ridge, and patients are referred to NYC cancer centers for treatment. If your clinician recommends a procedure the practice doesn't perform, ask the office about next steps.
"Watch it" or "biopsy it"?
Not every unusual mole needs a biopsy on the first visit. If a spot has one slightly odd feature but nothing clearly worrying, a dermatologist may record it, often with photos, and look again later. How a spot behaves over time tells a dermatologist a lot: a spot that stays the same is reassuring, and one that changes moves toward a biopsy.
A biopsy is more likely right away when a spot:
- Has changed, or shows several ABCDE features
- Bleeds, crusts or itches with no injury to explain it
- Looks clearly different from your other moles
If you're unsure why a dermatologist chose one path, ask. For more on monitoring, read what happens when a dermatologist wants to watch a spot.
When to book promptly rather than wait for a routine skin check
Book a visit soon if a mole or spot:
- Appeared after age 30 (the AAD recommends that a dermatologist look at any new mole that shows up at 30 or older)
- Is changing in size, shape, color or height
- Itches, bleeds, oozes or crusts without a clear cause
- Is a sore that doesn't heal, or heals and comes back
- Grows back after it was removed, which the AAD says calls for a dermatologist visit right away
Most moles are harmless, and having a spot examined is how you find out whether yours is.
Bay Ridge Dermatology is at 515 84th Street, 1st Floor, Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, NY 11209, and checks moles as part of its medical dermatology care. Its clinicians include Dr. Evangeline Perez, a board-certified dermatologist with more than 20 years of experience, and two physician assistants.
If a mole is on your mind, you can book online or call (347) 497-4984.
This article is general information, not medical advice. For advice about your own skin, see a dermatologist.

